5 Best Cornelius NC Italian Restaurants

For those looking for the best Cornelius, NC Italian restaurants, this lakeside town offers plenty of delicious options. From intimate pizzerias to elegant trattorias, there’s something for every Italian food lover. Whether you want traditional pasta, wood-fired pizza, or freshly baked bread, Cornelius has you covered. In this post, we’ll showcase the top Italian restaurants in the area for your next dining experience.

My methodology for ranking Cornelius, NC Italian restaurants

When it comes to deciding which local restaurants to include in my blog, I rely heavily on Google reviews. The following Italian restaurants have outstanding reviews and have been serving the Cornelius, NC community for many years.

Top 5 Italian Restaurants in Cornelius, NC

1. Maola’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

Proudly serving authentic Italian cuisine to the Cornelius and Lake Norman area since 2017. With over 35 years of culinary experience, this restaurant specializes in traditional homemade dishes. It offers a true taste of the old world.

Address: 20129 N Main St, Cornelius, NC 28031
Phone: (704) 896-1606
Website: maolas.com

Hours: Monday – Saturday, 11 AM – 9:30 PM; Sunday, 12 – 8 PM.

2. Prosciutto’s Pizzeria, Pub & Restaurant

In November 2005, Joel and Kelly Pfyffer opened Prosciutto’s Pizzeria and Pub in Cornelius. Since then, it has become a beloved part of the Lake Norman community. 

Known for its top-quality food and welcoming atmosphere, Prosciutto’s makes everyone feel like family. As a family-owned and operated restaurant, you’ll often see relatives helping out. 

Prosciutto’s serves gourmet New York-style brick-oven pizzas and calzones, crafted with the finest ingredients for an authentic taste.

Address: 20920 Torrence Chapel Rd Suite 6,7,8B, Cornelius, NC 28031
Phone: (704) 439-4444
Website: prosciuttos.com

Hours: Monday – Thursday, 4 – 10 PM; Friday – Sunday, 11 AM – 10 PM.

3. Ferrucci’s Old Tyme Italian Market

Craving homemade meals to take home, or searching for an authentic Italian specialty store? Perhaps a true New York butcher shop? Ferrucci’s Old Tyme Italian Market is where you’ll find it all.

Founded in 1999 by Brooklyn natives Maria and Tony Ferrucci, this market was designed for both cooking enthusiasts and food lovers alike. More than just a store, it revives the charm of a classic neighborhood grocery, where the senses come alive. 

Address: 20910 Torrence Chapel Rd, Cornelius, NC 28031
Phone: (704) 896-3190
Website: ferruccis.com

Hours: Tuesday – Friday, 10 AM – 6 PM; Saturday, 10 AM – 4 PM; Sunday – Monday, closed.

4. Brooklyn South Pizzeria

Brooklyn South Pizzeria, a family-owned restaurant, has proudly served the Lake Norman community since 1998. 

Every dough, sauce, and dish is prepared using time-honored family recipes. The staff, considered an extension of the family, works hard to ensure customers enjoy the best pizzas, freshest salads, and delicious Italian dishes. 

Guests are invited to visit any of the Lake Norman locations for a memorable and enjoyable dining experience.

Address: 19400 Jetton Rd # 201, Cornelius, NC 28031
Phone: (704) 896-2928
Website: brooklynsouthpizzeria.com

Hours: Monday – Thursday, 11 AM – 8 PM; Friday – Saturday, 11 AM – 9 PM; Sunday, 12 PM – 8 PM.

5. G.O.A.T. Pizza

G.O.A.T. Pizza is the creation of celebrity Chef David Burke and his partners, including local restaurateurs Joe Douglas and Rob Maynard. 

The restaurant serves great pizza, pasta, and smash burgers in a comfortable dining room. It’s a place where friends, neighbors, and families can gather to enjoy delicious food. 

The relaxed atmosphere encourages friendly conversation and shared meals in a welcoming space.

Address: 9623 Bailey Rd Suite 100, Cornelius, NC 28031
Phone: (704) 237-4728
Website: goatpizzanc.com

Hours: Monday, 11:30 AM – 10 PM; Tuesday – Wednesday, 11:30 AM – 9:30 PM; Thursday – Friday, 11:30 AM – 10 PM; Saturday – Sunday, 11 AM – 10 PM.

The Best of Cornelius | Italian Restaurants

Cornelius, NC offers many fantastic Italian dining options, making it easy to find a new favorite spot. From authentic pasta to wood-fired pizzas, these restaurants bring the flavors of Italy to town. Visit one of these top Italian restaurant picks for your next meal and enjoy the best Cornelius has to offer.